A Shropshire Lad
|
Key: V: Textual Variation. C: Commentary. Q: Question. Glossary
ASL LV “Westward on the high-hilled plains”
Top ▲ Glossary
Line | Word | Glossary |
8 | mill | The treadmill, part of the “hard-labour” used as punishment in prison |
9 | hueless | Colourless |
Top ▲ Commentary
Line | Commentary |
Date: Jan 1895 (fragment), May-July 1895 (draft) | |
1 | Westward: once again the emotional focus is to the west |
meter | Four line stanzas of seven syllables, rhymed alternately |
Top ▲ Variations
Line | Text | Textual variation |
1 | D | high-hilled] <hills and> |
3 | D | I think,] \ be sure, <for sure>, / |
4 | D | changeless] <ancient> |
5 | D | lads] <men> |
7 | D | <Other men,> \ They, I think, / for all they try, → They<,> must needs, \ no help / for all they try <,> |
8 | D | mill] <road<s>> \ round / |
9 | Dd1 | <There when down the west> |
9 | Dd2 | There, when ashen is the west |
10 | D | darkness hushes] twilight \ darkness / hushes → silence settles |
11 | Dd1 | Still above the sleeping breast |
11 | Dd2 | <Sure as \ <Still where> / lads lie down to rest> → Where the lad lies down to rest> |
12 | Dd1 | Stands] Bends |
13 | Dd1 | There to clearer \ later / eyes than mine |
13 | Dd2 | There to eyes that wake like mine \ clearer than / There on thoughts that once were mine |
Top ▲ Questions
Line | Question |
4 | Why do you think the poet preferred “changeless” to “ancient“? What does this alteration do to the meaning of the poem? |
8 | What does this line have to say about the human life? |
9 | What effect does the change from “ashen” to “hueless” have? |
11 | Compare the draft versions of this line:
With the final version: Where the lad lies down to rest. What are the merits of each? |
16 | How do you interpret the final line? What is the vow? |